TLDR;
This video compares nine midsize three-row SUVs, evaluating their strengths and weaknesses to determine the best option for families. The SUVs are assessed based on factors like interior quality, fuel economy, driving experience, cargo space, technology, and comfort. The Hyundai Palisade Hybrid emerges as the top pick due to its well-rounded performance, stylish interior, and practical features, while other models like the Kia Telluride, Toyota Grand Highlander, and GMC Acadia are also highlighted for specific strengths.
- Hyundai Palisade Hybrid is the best overall
- Kia Telluride is a close second with great styling and a responsive powertrain
- Toyota Grand Highlander excels in space and practicality
- GMC Acadia offers hands-free highway driving and ample cargo space
Intro [0:00]
The video introduces a comparison of nine midsize three-row SUVs to determine the best choice for families. Edmunds has gathered these vehicles to evaluate them side-by-side, using their rating system to pick a winner. The hosts emphasize their expertise in testing hundreds of cars each year to provide trusted reviews.
Mazda CX-90 [0:35]
The Mazda CX-90 is unique as the only plug-in hybrid in the comparison. It has a high-quality interior that rivals Acura and Lexus, and offers good fuel economy, with 27 miles of electric range in the plug-in hybrid version. However, the CX-90 suffers from jerky power delivery, especially in the plug-in hybrid model, and has the least cargo space and a cramped third row. The infotainment system is also frustrating to use. It's recommended only if a plug-in hybrid or driving dynamics are a top priority.
Nissan Pathfinder [3:00]
The Nissan Pathfinder stands out for its towing capacity, exceeding other SUVs in its class by 1,000 pounds. It's relatively affordable, even in higher trims, offering features like real leather, a digital gauge cluster, and rear window shades. The Pathfinder is quiet, comfortable, and has wide-opening rear doors with easy-to-access LATCH anchors for car seats. However, its adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assist are subpar, and the transmission can be slow to respond. The tech interface appears dated, and cargo space is limited. It's a good choice for those who need to tow or prioritize upfront cost.
Honda Pilot [5:36]
The Honda Pilot offers ample interior storage, including a shelf for the front passenger and large cup holders. It features a user-friendly infotainment system with Google integration and physical climate controls. Third-row access is made easy with a push-button seat tilt and slide mechanism. A fully loaded Pilot is more affordable than some competitors. However, the interior has a lot of hard plastic and feels basic compared to other SUVs. Fuel efficiency is also an issue, and the third row is tight for adults with non-reclining seatbacks.
GMC Acadia [8:13]
The GMC Acadia is a comfortable highway cruiser with a lot of cargo space and Super Cruise, a hands-free highway driving assist. It features a large screen with integrated Google apps. The Acadia has unmatched cargo space behind the third row. However, the seats aren't very comfortable, especially in the rear, and the third row feels cramped. The Denali Ultimate trim is expensive, costing $70,000. It's a good choice for highway driving, extra space, and Google ecosystem users.
VW Atlas [10:37]
The VW Atlas is known for its spacious third row, offering ample legroom and headroom. Access to the third row is easy with a tilt-and-slide second row. It also offers good small item storage and a large cargo area with flat-folding seats. However, the Atlas suffers from touch controls for important functions like temperature and volume, which are not illuminated at night. The power delivery can be jerky, and there is no hybrid option. The third-row headrests are uncomfortable. It's suitable for those who prioritize passenger space and cargo area and don't mind touch controls.
Ford Explorer [13:31]
The Ford Explorer has a responsive screen with an intuitive menu structure, wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and Google integration. It offers plenty of USB ports and the ability to open the car with a phone. The Explorer drives well, with an available twin-turbo V6 engine that provides the most power in its class. However, the interior is tight, and the rear seats are narrow and stiff. Legroom is limited, and the third row is uncomfortable for adults. Cargo space is smaller than other SUVs. It's recommended for those who value driving experience and technology over passenger comfort.
Toyota Grand Highlander [15:47]
The Toyota Grand Highlander offers a lot of space for both passengers and cargo, rivaling minivans and full-size SUVs. It excels in small item storage with numerous cubbies and cup holders. Device integration is a plus, with charge ports throughout the cabin and a household outlet. The Grand Highlander offers a choice of powertrains, including two hybrid options, with the hybrid max being a favorite for its power and fuel efficiency. The interior feels a bit plasticky, and the vehicle lacks a special feel. It's a practical and good choice, especially for those who prioritize space and hybrid options.
Kia Telluride [18:12]
The Kia Telluride is a well-rounded SUV with a stylish interior and a good tech system. It features a responsive hybrid system that improves upon the old V6, offering 35 miles per gallon. The ride quality is excellent, and the second-row seats are very comfortable. The location of the climate controls is a minor annoyance. It's a fantastic option with very few compromises, suitable for those who love its style and seek a versatile SUV.
Hyundai Palisade [20:17]
The Hyundai Palisade Hybrid is the Edmunds Top Rated Best of the Best, offering a comfortable, stylish, and practical driving experience. The suspension provides comfort and handling, and the hybrid powertrain delivers more power than the gas version, achieving up to 34 MPG combined. It features a large touch screen, an integrated dash cam, and a phenomenal tech suite. The interior is distinct and well-designed. The Palisade excels with a great second and third row, offering power adjustments and ample space. It's the best midsize three-row SUV for those seeking top-tier quality and features.
Edmunds' Take [22:49]
The hosts discuss their preferences for a "Franken SUV," combining the best features from each model. They choose the Explorer's powertrain for its power, the Telluride's styling, especially the interior, and the Korean SUVs' technology for its ease of use. The Pathfinder's air conditioning and the Atlas's dual air vents are also highlighted.
