TLDR;
Caleb Savant shares his perspective on whether SDI (Sonoran Desert Institute) is a scam, drawing from his extensive experience as a traditionally trained gunsmith and his personal experience as an SDI student. He emphasizes that SDI is not a scam but an entry-level Gunsmithing program that can be valuable, especially for those who cannot attend in-person trade schools. He highlights the importance of realistic expectations, the value of the foundational knowledge provided, and the potential for graduates to be hired for entry-level positions.
- SDI is not a scam, but an entry-level Gunsmithing program.
- Realistic expectations are crucial; it's not a substitute for hands-on trade schools.
- The program provides valuable foundational knowledge in firearms and related sciences.
- Graduates are hirable for entry-level Gunsmithing positions.
- Hands-on trade schools are better, but online education is still good.
Introduction [0:05]
Caleb introduces the topic of whether SDI is a scam, a subject he considers too controversial for his Brownells channel, so he's addressing it on his personal channel. He clarifies that he's providing his opinion as a traditionally trained gunsmith with years of experience, including having gone through the SDI program after already establishing himself in the field. He encourages listeners to simply listen to the audio if they prefer, as there are no visuals accompanying the discussion.
Background [1:31]
Caleb provides background on his gunsmithing experience to establish his credibility. He has been a professional gunsmith since 2012, learning through a paid apprenticeship rather than formal schooling. He traveled around Louisiana, learning from older gunsmiths and reading old books. He specialized in restoring old guns and fabricating parts for obsolete firearms, working in general-purpose gunsmith shops and a warranty center for major firearms brands. He also has experience as a shop foreman and as a guest instructor at in-person gunsmith schools.
SDI Experience [5:44]
Caleb discusses his decision to attend SDI in 2020, driven by the VA's encouragement to use his GI Bill. Already a successful gunsmith, he saw it as an opportunity to gain certification and receive a housing allowance. He emphasizes that his success as a gunsmith was not due to SDI. He was motivated to share his views after seeing videos criticizing SDI, which he felt misrepresented the program's value.
Entry-Level Classes [8:21]
Caleb addresses criticisms of SDI's entry-level classes, explaining that they are designed to provide a foundation in firearms, ballistics, and reloading. He argues that understanding these basics is essential for gunsmithing, countering the notion that experienced shooters already know everything. He stresses the importance of realistic expectations, noting that some students may be disappointed if they expect to immediately start building advanced rifles.
Curriculum and Accreditation [10:38]
Caleb explains that SDI's curriculum includes writing, science, and math, similar to in-person gunsmithing schools. He emphasizes the importance of math in gunsmithing for precise measurements and safety. He notes that the inclusion of these classes is necessary for accreditation and GI Bill eligibility. He defends the muzzle loader building class, arguing that it teaches fundamental skills in working with steel and wood, which are still relevant in modern firearms.
Improvements and Discussion Boards [13:37]
Caleb acknowledges that SDI's courses could use some improvements, including the discussion boards. He emphasizes that students get out of the program what they put into it, encouraging them to actively study the material rather than just trying to pass. He invites viewers to ask questions in the comments about specific arguments against SDI.
SDI as a Scam [14:39]
Caleb reiterates that SDI is not a scam, emphasizing that it provides an entry-level Gunsmithing degree. He clarifies that SDI does not teach lathe and mill work, recommending supplemental courses for those skills. He addresses the argument that an SDI degree doesn't make someone more hirable, stating that he would choose a candidate with an SDI degree over someone without one for an entry-level gunsmithing position.
Hirable [15:25]
Caleb uses a hypothetical hiring scenario to illustrate the value of an SDI degree. He asserts that, assuming all other factors are equal, he would always hire the candidate with the SDI degree for a gunsmithing position. He emphasizes that his background and experience in a management position as a gunsmith should lend weight to his opinion.
In-Person vs. Online [18:12]
Caleb acknowledges that in-person gunsmithing schools offer the advantage of hands-on lathe and mill work instruction. However, he recognizes that not everyone can attend in-person schools due to time and location constraints. He suggests that online degrees like SDI are a good alternative, but stresses the importance of realistic expectations. He concludes by reiterating that SDI is not a scam and that online programs can be valuable if students actively participate and seek knowledge.