Brief Summary
This video reviews the live-action remake of "How to Train Your Dragon," comparing it to the original animated film. The reviewer discusses the casting choices, visual aspects, and overall impact of the remake, noting its faithfulness to the source material and its potential appeal to general audiences. The review also touches on the broader trend of live-action remakes and the challenges of adapting animated stories.
- The live-action remake is very faithful to the original animated movie.
- Mason Thames and Nico Parker were well-cast as Hiccup and Astrid, respectively.
- The CGI and visual aspects of the film are impressive, particularly the dragons and flying sequences.
- The movie may appeal more to general audiences than to die-hard fans of the original.
Introduction
The video introduces the live-action remake of "How to Train Your Dragon," highlighting that it's Universal's first attempt at adapting a 3D animated movie into live-action. The reviewer notes that the story revolves around Hiccup and Toothless, characters from opposing sides of a war who become friends. The review promises to be spoiler-free.
Expectations and Initial Thoughts
The reviewer expresses surprise that 3D animated movies are now being adapted into live-action, following Disney's trend with their classic animations. While dedicated movie fans are often critical of these remakes, general audiences tend to enjoy seeing animated stories brought to life. The reviewer was unsure what to expect from Universal's adaptation but was intrigued by the trailers, which seemed faithful to the original. The reviewer hopes that competition from other studios might encourage Disney to improve their live-action remakes.
Overall Impression and Comparison to the Original
The reviewer believes that general audiences will love the live-action "How to Train Your Dragon" because it closely follows the original movie. It's challenging to review such a faithful remake, as much of what is great about it is also true of the animated version. The reviewer aims to focus on the live-action elements, acknowledging the well-known story and character dynamics from the original film.
Casting and Performances
Mason Thames' portrayal of Hiccup is praised for capturing the character's dorky and quirky nature without imitating the original voice actor. Nico Parker's Astrid is also well-received, with the live-action version possibly developing the relationship between Hiccup and Astrid slightly better by adding a tense dynamic due to Hiccup's privileged status as the chief's son. The entire live-action cast is considered perfectly cast, including Gerard Butler reprising his voice role.
Visuals and Atmosphere
The reviewer appreciates the atmosphere created in the live-action movie, noting that live-action remakes can sometimes be limited visually compared to animation. While the visuals may not surpass the animated film, the dragons, village, arenas, and dragon's nest are fun to see in live-action form. The action sequences, especially those involving Hiccup and Toothless flying, are majestic, enhanced by impressive CGI.
Impact and Recommendation
Despite concerns about replacing animation, the reviewer admits to enjoying the live-action movie and feeling that it captures the essence of the original. While recommending the animated film as the priority, the reviewer acknowledges that the live-action version could provide a similar experience. The reviewer discusses the catch-22 of remakes: staying too close to the original invites criticism for being lazy, while adding too much new material alienates fans.
Negatives and Potential for a Trilogy
The first 40 minutes of the movie feel strange due to the shot-for-shot remake following the animated film's rhythm, which doesn't translate well to live-action. The movie improves once Hiccup and Toothless begin interacting. The reviewer is unsure about the need for a complete trilogy in live-action, as it may not justify its existence beyond showcasing the characters in real life.
Final Thoughts and Ratings
The reviewer believes that many people will be happy with the live-action adaptation because it safely translates the original movie. The reviewer wonders if this approach is the best way to avoid controversy. The reviewer gives the movie the following ratings:
- Action: 3.5 stars
- Comedy: 2.5 stars (humor is lost in live-action)
- Drama: 3.5 stars (story is great, but the rhythm is off)
- Horror: 0.5 stars (one scene might be frightening for kids)
- Suspense: 2 stars (familiarity with the story reduces suspense)
- Casual Moviegoers: A+
- Cinephiles: B+
- Critically: B-
The reviewer concludes that the live-action "How to Train Your Dragon" is worth watching in theaters due to its faithful adaptation of an amazing film.
