Why Man Utd’s squad isn’t as bad as you think

Why Man Utd’s squad isn’t as bad as you think

TLDR;

Manchester United’s squad is uneven, but the problems cannot be judged simply by labelling individual players as good or bad. Their attack creates chances at a level comparable with Champions League contenders, while limitations in width, long contracts, midfield protection and defensive profiles affect how well the squad functions together. The discussion argues that better tactics could help the current midfield, that modern defenders could improve both defence and midfield, and that INEOS should eventually move from addressing one area at a time to making more holistic, targeted signings.

  • United rank fourth for non-penalty expected goals, although their chance quality per shot suggests room to improve their shot selection.
  • Recruitment and contract commitments have left the squad short of suitable wide options and restricted further signings.
  • The midfield’s weaknesses are amplified by Carrick’s defensive shape, which can expose central space when opponents break the press.
  • Better central protection and defenders able to step into midfield could improve several areas at once.
  • INEOS’s sequential recruitment strategy risks becoming a cycle as existing players age; a more holistic approach is needed once the squad reaches a stronger baseline.

Intro [0:00]

Manchester United have weaknesses in several parts of the squad, including limited cover at left-back and uncertainty around players affected by injuries. However, judging players only by the team’s recent results can be misleading: a poor team performance does not automatically mean every individual is inadequate. Squad strength also depends on how players’ roles and abilities fit together, and on whether the coach’s system makes the most of them. The analysis therefore focuses on how the squad functions as a whole rather than rating each player in isolation.

Is Man Utd's attack actually good? [0:59]

United’s attack is producing strong underlying numbers. They rank fourth for non-penalty expected goals, meaning the quality of chances they create is comparable to that of teams competing for Champions League places. Their expected goals per shot are lower than those of some of the other top sides, which points to possible weaknesses in shot selection, but the overall chance creation is strong.

The attack’s limitations are more about balance than a lack of talent. Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo can play wide but are more naturally suited to operating inside, while the squad’s other wide options include Patrick Dorgu, brought in with a wing-back role in mind, Marcus Rashford, whom United tried to move on, and Amad, who is a credible option on the flank. The team’s best attacking players have encouraged a narrower style, leaving less upside if a future manager wants to make greater use of width. This reflects the risks of hiring consecutive managers with very different approaches to squad building.

Why Man Utd struggled to sign more forwards [3:16]

United’s recruitment options are constrained not only by available money but also by existing contracts and wages. Rashford remains under contract until 2028, despite the club having tried to sell him, which limits its ability to bring in another wide player. Joshua Zirkzee is contracted until 2029, so even if United want a different option while Benjamin Šeško is injured, they must consider the financial commitment to Zirkzee.

Long contracts can also create future risks elsewhere. Cunha and Mbeumo will be in their thirties by the end of their deals, so their performance levels will need to remain strong. Manuel Ugarte is also contracted until 2029; had he been available to move on, his departure might have created more room for midfield recruitment. These commitments make it harder to fix a squad by simply identifying a weakness and signing a replacement.

Should Man Utd have signed more midfielders? [4:46]

United invested heavily in midfield, bringing in André Santos, Youri Tielemans and Carlos Baleba. Santos and Tielemans were relatively lower-cost additions, while Baleba arrived later in the window to address concerns about the midfield’s ability to defend large spaces. The criticism that the club should have bought one expensive, more complete midfielder instead reflects a debate about whether it is better to spend heavily on a single elite player or make several cheaper additions.

A top-level midfielder such as Declan Rice or Elliot Anderson may offer greater quality on both sides of the ball. Less expensive players may have useful strengths but also more pronounced weaknesses. That does not necessarily make them poor signings, but it means the coaching system must account for their limitations and find ways to reduce their exposure. The analysis argues that United’s current defensive tactics have not done enough to protect their midfielders.

How Carrick's tactics made the midfield look worse [6:16]

Against Aston Villa, United defended in a 4-2-4 shape that could initially provide extra numbers in central areas. Bruno Fernandes and Mbeumo started deeper to help protect the middle, while Noussair Mazraoui tracked Morgan Rogers as he moved inside. But the shape was vulnerable when United pressed aggressively: Villa moved players to pull United’s forwards and midfielders out of position, opening routes into the central space.

As the press was triggered, Fernandes jumped towards goalkeeper Emiliano Martínez, while Ian Maatsen moved higher and drew Amad away. Mbeumo then had to move out towards Pau Torres, reducing the central protection. Tielemans stepped forward and Leny Yoro moved up to track a Villa player, but when Villa threatened to play into the channel, United’s back line dropped and the midfielders had to retreat to cover. Tielemans could not effectively cover both the player in front of him and the danger opening up behind.

Villa exploited the same weakness in a later build-up. With Tielemans high and Fernandes blocking a passing lane, Torres was again available to receive the ball. Mazraoui had to consider the channel behind him, allowing Rogers to drop into space; Villa then used a short combination to break the press. The move left United’s midfielders facing several free opponents, with Kobbie Mainoo having to cover a large area. Villa did not fully capitalise, but better decisions by opponents could expose the same problem repeatedly. The point is that Mainoo and Tielemans may look less capable partly because the system is not protecting them.

How better tactics can fix the midfield [12:03]

United’s 4-2-4 press can be manipulated because aggressive pressure on the opposition’s defenders pulls players away from the centre. Since the midfielders are not especially strong at covering large spaces, opening those areas leaves them exposed. Many Premier League sides instead use a more compact 4-4-2 diamond, with a central pivot and players positioned around the outside of the diamond to help guide opponents towards the flanks.

In that structure, the pivot can move across to protect whichever half-space the ball enters, while the wide midfielders shift to support the full-back and retain numbers centrally. The team can then press and squeeze opponents near the touchline rather than allowing them to progress through the middle. A better use of the defensive line could provide further support: when pressing creates gaps, an extra defender can step forward to deal with an opponent moving into space. This would make United’s midfielders less vulnerable and help their strengths show more clearly.

Why Man Utd need to sign better defenders [14:16]

United’s centre-backs have different strengths, but the current options do not all suit the demands of a modern high press. Harry Maguire is strong at defending in the box and can help build from the back, but his lack of speed makes it risky to push him into midfield and then ask him to recover. Lisandro Martínez is more suited to stepping forward and covering space, but his height can be a disadvantage in the penalty area. Matthijs de Ligt’s recurring injuries have also limited his availability.

Recruiting starting-level centre-backs who can step forward to cover midfield spaces and still defend the box well could improve both the back line and the midfield. It would also give young defenders Leny Yoro and Ayden Heaven a more stable environment in which to develop, rather than exposing them to defensive instability. Full-backs also need attention: Luke Shaw has little cover, Dorgu may be an option in a deeper role, and while Diogo Dalot offers useful backup on either side, United could benefit from a stronger starting option. Improving full-backs could also strengthen the attack.

The main problem with INEOS's approach [17:21]

United’s recruitment areas are interconnected, so signing attackers and midfielders does not solve those parts of the team if weaknesses at the back continue to affect them. Adding strong defenders could make the squad more coherent, but it would not fix everything. A further risk is that the sequential strategy—addressing one part of the pitch in each transfer window—can leave earlier signings ageing while the club moves on to the next problem. Several attacking players, including Mbeumo, Cunha and Fernandes, are already moving out of the squad’s peak-age group, so United may need to revisit the forward line by the time their defence is addressed.

The alternative is a more holistic approach: assess how individual signings affect the whole team rather than treating each area as a separate project. A centre-back could improve both defensive stability and midfield protection, while a right-sided forward could address attacking balance as well as add depth. That approach will be easier once United establish a sufficiently strong baseline across the pitch, but after the next recruitment cycle the club should be better placed to make targeted additions that improve the squad as a whole.

Watch the Video

Date: 11/20/2026 Source: www.youtube.com
Share

Stay Informed with Quality Articles

Discover curated summaries and insights from across the web. Save time while staying informed.

© 2024 BriefRead