TLDR;
Psychiatrist and neuroscientist Jeffrey M. Schwartz explains how directed attention and mindfulness can reshape the brain, rather than the brain determining everything about the mind. Drawing on his work with obsessive–compulsive disorder (OCD), he presents a four-step method for responding to unhelpful thoughts and habits: relabel, reframe, refocus and revalue. He also demonstrates a short breathing practice and describes research showing that constructive reinterpretation of emotional events can strengthen executive brain activity and reduce emotional responses.
- The brain can produce intrusive or misleading thoughts, but they do not define a person.
- Mindfulness helps people choose where to direct attention and develop more helpful habits.
- Reinterpreting an upsetting situation can engage the planning parts of the brain and calm emotional processing.
How Attention Can Change the Brain [1:13]
Schwartz argues that the familiar view—“the mind is what the brain does”—is incomplete. The brain generates thoughts and impulses, but the active mind can choose whether and how to attend to them. Repeated choices of attention can alter brain wiring, so the mind can influence how the brain works.
He describes several connected brain regions: the orbitofrontal cortex (OFC), involved in error detection; the amygdala, associated with fear and emotion; the ventral striatum, part of the reward system; and the caudate nucleus, involved in habits. Reward and habit systems are closely linked and both involve dopamine. Pleasure can therefore reinforce habits, sometimes without conscious awareness, making deliberate attention and planning important for keeping reward-seeking in balance.
OCD, Deceptive Brain Messages and Neuroplasticity [4:35]
OCD can involve overactive brain circuits that bring unwanted thoughts and urges into conscious awareness, even when a person recognises them as inappropriate. Schwartz’s work on OCD found that a four-step cognitive behavioural and mindfulness-based treatment changed the relationship between the brain’s error-detection and habit circuits. Brain imaging showed that therapy and mindful awareness could alter brain function—an example of neuroplasticity, the brain’s ability to change.
Schwartz connects this to Hebb’s principle: neurons that fire together wire together. Some patterns become established early in life, before a person has enough understanding to assess them. He calls false or inaccurate thoughts, and unhelpful impulses that pull people away from their goals, “deceptive brain messages”. Family dynamics can contribute to these patterns, but awareness can help people change them and may also improve relationships. He draws on the Buddhist teaching that suffering is universal, while emphasising that mindfulness can help people respond differently.
Cognitive Distortions and the Wise Advocate [8:01]
Schwartz explains how the quantum Zeno effect—a principle from physics—has been applied to neuroscience. In his account, sustained attention affects brain activity: the brain becomes shaped by what a person focuses on and by the manner and context of that focus. Attention can be directed deliberately rather than simply captured by every thought or external stimulus.
Cognitive therapy helps identify and correct thinking errors, including all-or-nothing thinking (“I must be perfect”), catastrophising (“One mistake will get me fired”), discounting the positive, emotional reasoning, mind-reading, shame-inducing “should” statements, negative comparisons and false expectations. Recognising these distortions makes it possible to question them and choose a more accurate response.
The “true self” means seeing oneself through one’s sincere values and goals, while treating one’s emotions and needs with care. Schwartz calls the inner capacity to recognise deceptive thoughts and make considered decisions the “wise advocate”. It can be understood as a psychological tool or, for those who prefer, as a spiritual or sacred presence. Its purpose is to support choices that serve a person’s long-term wellbeing.
The Four Steps: Relabel, Reframe, Refocus and Revalue [14:36]
Schwartz’s four-step method is intended to help change unhealthy thinking and habits. Relabel means accurately identifying a thought or urge rather than accepting a misleading interpretation. Reframe means recognising that an unwanted impulse may be a false brain message—not the person’s identity—summed up by the phrase, “This is not me; it is just my brain.”
Refocus means deliberately turning attention towards a constructive and wholesome activity, even while an unwanted thought is present. Repeating this response helps build more useful patterns in the brain. Revalue means seeing deceptive thoughts as sensations or mental events rather than truths that must be obeyed. With practice, the four steps can become more automatic, supporting changes in habits, values and responses.
Mindfulness and a Short Breathing Practice [17:16]
Schwartz describes mindfulness as an activity of attention: awareness of what is happening now, combined with a choice about where and how to focus. Attention may be narrow or broad, but it need not be controlled by the brain’s impulses or by distractions. Mindfulness also involves acceptance. Accepting that a thought is present, without fighting it or treating it as the self, can make it easier to redirect attention.
He leads a brief breathing exercise. Participants sit comfortably, close their eyes and notice the air passing at the nostrils, counting “one” while breathing in and “two” while breathing out. They can count onwards, up to ten, then begin again; when the mind wanders, they simply return to one. Observing the breath can settle breathing and strengthen awareness. Schwartz says mindfulness can reduce stress, anxiety and depression, support more rational decisions, and improve conscious emotion regulation.
Changing the Emotional Response by Changing the Narrative [24:46]
Schwartz describes a laboratory experiment led by James Gross, with Kevin Ochsner as a postdoctoral researcher. Participants viewed emotional scenes and were prompted either to “attend” to them or to “reappraise” them—that is, to change the way they interpreted what was happening. In one example, people viewing upsetting accident scenes imagined being emergency medical technicians who needed to stay calm to assess the situation. This constructive narrative reduced their emotional response.
Brain imaging showed that simply attending to upsetting scenes increased activity in the error-detection circuit and the amygdala, which processes fear and emotion. Reappraisal activated areas of the prefrontal cortex, including the lateral prefrontal cortex, involved in maintaining a strategy and planning. When executive activity increased through constructive reinterpretation, activity in emotional-processing areas decreased. Schwartz concludes that mindfulness and the four steps can help people direct attention differently, reshape brain activity and apply this approach in their own lives, families and communities.