TLDR;
This YouTube video features a commentary and summary of two episodes of Doctor Who: "Rose" and "The End of the World." The commentators discuss character development, plot points, and the overall quality of the episodes, often with humorous and critical remarks. Key takeaways include:
- Rose's character is a point of contention, with some finding her relatable and others viewing her as flawed and selfish.
- The show explores themes of death, sacrifice, and the potential consequences of altering time.
- The commentators analyze the characters' motivations and actions, often drawing parallels to other sci-fi and fantasy series.
- The episodes introduce recurring elements such as the Bad Wolf storyline and the Time War.
Start of Doctor Who Saath [0:00]
The video begins with introductions of the commentators: Ru, Sean, and Eric. Eric jokes about being the DEI hire. They express excitement about reviewing Doctor Who, specifically mentioning that Eric is not on mushrooms this time, a reference to a previous Twilight commentary.
The Idiots Lantern [1:17]
The commentators begin watching "Rose," the first episode of the revived Doctor Who series. They discuss the British setting, noting the realistic portrayal of apartments and the slightly outdated technology. The commentators discuss Rose's outfit and how it was a popular style in 2005. They discuss Rose's initial encounter with the Autons and her reaction to the situation. They question her decision-making and discuss the creepiness of the mannequins. The group jokes about how calm Rose is during the mannequin attack.
Rose Meets the Doctor [6:15]
The commentators discuss the Doctor's arrival and his cryptic warnings. They analyze Rose's decision to trust him, despite the bizarre circumstances. The group jokes about the Doctor's initial interactions with Rose and his eccentric personality. They discuss the logic of the situation and whether Rose should have gone home.
The TARDIS [10:55]
The commentators discuss the TARDIS and its "bigger on the inside" feature. They joke about Rose's reaction to the TARDIS and her skepticism. The group discusses the computer and the search engines. They analyze the character of Clive and his obsession with the Doctor.
Aliens Throughout History [12:11]
The commentators discuss the Doctor's explanation of his role in history. They analyze the character of Mickey and his reaction to Rose's disappearance. The group jokes about Bri's enjoyment of the show and her love of danger. They discuss the design of the car and its British origins.
Auton Mickey [13:51]
The commentators discuss the Auton Mickey and his creepy demeanor. They analyze Rose's reaction to the situation and her lack of panic. The group jokes about the Michael Jackson reference and the Autons' fighting skills. They discuss the Sonic Screwdriver and its limitations.
The Nestene Consciousness [15:38]
The commentators discuss the Nestene Consciousness and its plan to destroy humanity. They analyze Rose's role in defeating the Nestene Consciousness. The group jokes about the special effects and the cheesy dialogue. They discuss Mickey's reaction to Rose's decision to leave with the Doctor.
The Doctor's Invitation [22:37]
The commentators discuss the Doctor's invitation to Rose to travel with him. They analyze Mickey's role in Rose's life and whether she should stay with him. The group jokes about Bri's willingness to leave her partner for the Doctor. They discuss the logistics of time travel and its impact on relationships.
Early Access Plug [24:15]
The commentators take a break to promote their Patreon and YouTube membership. They explain the benefits of becoming a member, including early access to videos and uncut content.
The End of the World [25:17]
The commentators begin watching "The End of the World," the second episode of the series. They discuss the concept of traveling to the future and the implications of witnessing the Earth's destruction. The group jokes about their own preferences for time travel and their potential actions. They discuss the design of the spaceship and its futuristic elements.
The Smartest Person [27:41]
The commentators discuss who is the smartest person in the group. They debate the merits of each commentator and their respective strengths. The group jokes about Sean's intellectual abilities and his tendency to talk about women.
The Guests [29:31]
The commentators discuss the various alien species on board the spaceship. They analyze the design of the aliens and their unique characteristics. The group jokes about the Blue Man Group and the Ood. They discuss the last human and her obsession with moisturizers.
iPod [32:14]
The commentators discuss the iPod and its significance as a cultural artifact. They joke about the idea of watching the Earth die while listening to music. The group analyzes the motivations of the various guests on board the spaceship. They discuss the plumber and her role in the episode.
The Little Robots [33:36]
The commentators discuss the little robots and their deadly nature. They analyze Rose's reaction to the situation and her growing acceptance of the Doctor's world. The group jokes about Rose's racism and the Doctor's alien identity. They discuss the concept of a designated driver and its relevance to the episode.
5 Billion Years Ago [35:12]
The commentators discuss the timeline of the episode and the vastness of time. They analyze the Doctor's reaction to the Earth's destruction and his stoic demeanor. The group jokes about the gravity pockets and the design of the alien suits. They discuss the sun filter and its importance for the human characters.
The Last Pure Human [36:17]
The commentators discuss the character of Cassandra and her obsession with being the last pure human. They analyze her motivations and her disdain for other species. The group jokes about Cassandra's appearance and her numerous surgeries. They discuss the concept of consensual danger and its relevance to the episode.
Sean Sexist? [37:34]
The commentators discuss Sean's jokes about women and whether they are sexist. They debate the merits of his humor and his intentions. The group jokes about creating a compilation of Sean's sexist jokes. They discuss the AI and its knowledge of their channel.
The End of the World
The commentators discuss the impending destruction of the Earth. They analyze the Doctor's reaction to the situation and his determination to save the day. The group jokes about the traditional ballad and its appropriateness for the occasion. They discuss Rose's attempts to save the day and her resourcefulness.
The Adherents of the Repeated Meme
The commentators discuss the Adherents of the Repeated Meme and their role in the episode. They analyze their motivations and their creepy demeanor. The group jokes about their teeth and their overall design. They discuss the scale of the episode and its cataclysmic events.
Time Lord
The commentators discuss the Time Lord and his powers. They analyze Rose's reaction to the Doctor's abilities and her growing understanding of his world. The group jokes about the Doctor's origins and his connection to Dr. Seuss. They discuss the logistics of surviving in a burning spaceship.
Cassandra's Plan
The commentators discuss Cassandra's plan to ransom the guests on board the spaceship. They analyze her motivations and her lack of empathy. The group jokes about her technicalities and her legal loopholes. They discuss Rose's decision to stay with the Doctor and her willingness to abandon her normal life.
Moisturize Me
The commentators discuss Cassandra's death and her final words. They analyze the Doctor's reaction to her death and his lack of remorse. The group jokes about the big head and its fate. They discuss the philosophical implications of watching the Earth explode and its impact on one's perspective.
The Absurd
The commentators discuss the concept of the Absurd and its relevance to the episode. They analyze the Doctor's philosophy and his acceptance of the meaningless of life. The group jokes about Albert Camus and his writings. They discuss the Time War and its impact on the Doctor's character.
Are You Racist?
The commentators discuss the Doctor's status as the last of the Time Lords. They analyze Rose's reaction to his loneliness and her growing connection to him. The group jokes about the possibility of Time Lord-human hybrids and the implications for purity. They discuss Rose's flirting and her attraction to the Doctor.
The Last Margarita
The commentators discuss the giant margarita and its significance as a symbol of the Earth's destruction. They analyze the Doctor's stoicism and his ability to cope with loss. The group jokes about Sean's age and his recognition of the margarita. They discuss the character of Rose's mom and her potential return.
Zombie Grandma
The commentators begin watching "The Unquiet Dead," the third episode of the series. They discuss the setting of the episode and its historical context. The group jokes about zombie grandma and her violent tendencies. They discuss the budget of the show and its limitations.
1860s
The commentators discuss the historical setting of the episode and its depiction of Victorian England. They analyze the social norms and the attitudes towards death. The group jokes about the lack of hygiene and the prevalence of disease. They discuss the character of Gwyneth and her psychic abilities.
Billy Piper
The commentators discuss the actress Billy Piper and her previous roles. They analyze her performance in the episode and her chemistry with David Tenant. The group jokes about her role as a call girl and her knowledge of prostitutes. They discuss the character of Charles Dickens and his appearance in the episode.
Charles Dickens
The commentators discuss the character of Charles Dickens and his role in the episode. They analyze his appearance and his personality. The group jokes about his mutton chops and his literary achievements. They discuss the lack of showers in Victorian England and the importance of hygiene.
Christmas Carolers
The commentators discuss the Christmas Carolers and their significance in the episode. They analyze the social customs of the time and the role of religion. The group jokes about Jesus and his impact on the five-hour work week. They discuss the blue-eyed people and their connection to the ghosts.
Dickens Run
The commentators discuss Dickens' reaction to the ghosts and his decision to help Rose and the Doctor. They analyze his motivations and his bravery. The group jokes about his normal attire and his lack of fear. They discuss the blue aura around the possessed woman and its significance.
Chloroform
The commentators discuss the use of chloroform and its prevalence in the 1800s. They analyze the ease with which people could be killed and the lack of consequences. The group jokes about Jack the Ripper and his crimes. They discuss the best short story ever written and its author.
The Chase is ONN
The commentators discuss the chase scene and the Doctor's pursuit of the ghosts. They analyze Rose's relationship with the Doctor and her growing attraction to him. The group jokes about the age difference between them and the implications for their relationship. They discuss the ghosts' ability to possess the dead and their connection to gas.
Gas Ghosts
The commentators discuss the nature of the gas ghosts and their powers. They analyze the science behind their abilities and their connection to decomposition. The group jokes about Sean's knowledge of human anatomy and his medical background. They discuss the fast gas and its properties.
Science Now Awesome
The commentators discuss the philosophical implications of the episode and its exploration of life and death. They analyze Dickens' transformation and his newfound appreciation for life. The group jokes about socialism and its role in the episode. They discuss the gas ghost and its connection to fire.
Butcher's Boy
The commentators discuss the character of the butcher's boy and his connection to the ghosts. They analyze his appearance and his role in the episode. The group jokes about Billy Piper and her previous roles. They discuss the flu and its impact on the characters' lives.
The Sight
The commentators discuss Gwyneth's psychic abilities and her connection to the rift. They analyze her role in the episode and her importance to the plot. The group jokes about the table wrappers and their significance. They discuss the seance and its potential dangers.
The Other Side of the Universe
The commentators discuss the ghosts' plan to open the rift and unleash their forces upon the world. They analyze their motivations and their connection to the other side of the universe. The group jokes about the lack of decent burials and the importance of respecting the dead. They discuss the Doctor's seriousness and his commitment to protecting life.
Aliens Like Foreigners
The commentators discuss the nature of the aliens and their connection to the human world. They analyze their motivations and their goals. The group jokes about the different moralities and the need to adapt. They discuss the rift chance and its significance to the plot.
Gazebo
The commentators discuss the gazebo and its connection to the rift. They analyze the symbolism of the location and its importance to the story. The group jokes about purple toes and the scientist's curiosity. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of the unknown.
Listen to Your Master
The commentators discuss the ghosts' plan to unleash their forces upon the world. They analyze their motivations and their connection to the other side of the universe. The group jokes about the gas and its properties. They discuss the importance of listening to Rose and her advice.
The Reasonable Response
The commentators discuss the Doctor's plan to stop the ghosts and close the rift. They analyze his strategy and his reliance on Rose's help. The group jokes about the gas and its explosive potential. They discuss Gwyneth's sacrifice and her heroism.
The End
The commentators discuss the aftermath of the battle and the consequences of the ghosts' actions. They analyze Dickens' transformation and his newfound appreciation for life. The group jokes about the mystery of Edwin Drood and the blue Elementals. They discuss the Doctor's departure and his invitation to Rose to continue traveling with him.
Aliens of London
The commentators preview the next episode, "Aliens of London." They discuss the recap and its focus on Rose's actions. The group jokes about Mickey's reaction to Rose's return and his potential jealousy. They discuss the upcoming events and the new challenges that the Doctor and Rose will face.
Six Months
The commentators discuss the time jump and its impact on Rose's relationships. They analyze Mickey's reaction to Rose's disappearance and his potential involvement in the investigation. The group jokes about the aliens of London and their plans for Earth. They discuss the upcoming events and the new challenges that the Doctor and Rose will face.
The Bad Wolf
The commentators discuss the Bad Wolf reference and its significance to the plot. They analyze the character of Mickey and his potential to become a villain. The group jokes about the three little piggies and the big bad wolf. They discuss the coffee shop and its connection to the aliens.
The Prime Minister
The commentators discuss the Prime Minister and his role in the episode. They analyze his behavior and his connection to the aliens. The group jokes about the British 9/11 and its impact on the world. They discuss the adrenaline junkies and their motivations.
Harriet Jones
The commentators discuss the character of Harriet Jones and her rise to power. They analyze her motivations and her potential to become a leader. The group jokes about the emergency protocols and their significance. They discuss the aliens' plan to infiltrate the government and take control of Earth.
Fatty
The commentators discuss the aliens' physical appearance and their connection to fat. They analyze their motivations and their goals. The group jokes about the posters and their significance. They discuss the first contact and its potential to change the world.
Mickey
The commentators discuss Mickey's role in the episode and his potential to become a hero. They analyze his motivations and his relationship with Rose. The group jokes about the Tardis and its ability to travel through time. They discuss the Bad Wolf and its significance to the plot.
The Aliens
The commentators discuss the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their motivations for doing so. They analyze their tactics and their weaknesses. The group jokes about the emergency protocols and their effectiveness. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Tool
The commentators discuss the tool and its significance to the plot. They analyze its function and its potential to save the world. The group jokes about the morticians and their role in preparing the dead. They discuss the makeup and its importance to the process.
The Doctor's Energy
The commentators discuss the Doctor's energy and his determination to save the world. They analyze his motivations and his commitment to protecting life. The group jokes about the psychic wallet and its potential uses. They discuss the aliens' plan to invade Earth and their motivations for doing so.
The Pig
The commentators discuss the pig and its significance to the plot. They analyze its role in the aliens' plan and its connection to the Prime Minister. The group jokes about the space pig and its fate. They discuss the aliens' behavior and their lack of respect for human life.
The Forehead
The commentators discuss the aliens' physical appearance and their lack of eyebrows. They analyze their motivations and their goals. The group jokes about the forehead and its significance. They discuss the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so.
The Human Suit
The commentators discuss the human suit and its significance to the plot. They analyze its design and its function. The group jokes about the squelchy sound and its creepiness. They discuss the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so.
The Hand
The commentators discuss the hand and its significance to the plot. They analyze its role in the aliens' plan and its connection to the Doctor. The group jokes about the aliens' motivations and their goals. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Doctor's Energy
The commentators discuss the Doctor's energy and his determination to save the world. They analyze his motivations and his commitment to protecting life. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
Mickey's Back
The commentators discuss Mickey's return and his role in the episode. They analyze his motivations and his relationship with Rose. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Plumber
The commentators discuss the plumber and her role in the episode. They analyze her motivations and her connection to the aliens. The group jokes about the psychic wallet and its potential uses. They discuss the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Gelth
The commentators discuss the Gelth and their plan to invade Earth. They analyze their motivations and their connection to the rift. The group jokes about the seance and its potential dangers. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Sonic Screwdriver
The commentators discuss the Sonic Screwdriver and its limitations. They analyze its role in the episode and its effectiveness against the aliens. The group jokes about the Doctor's abilities and his resourcefulness. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Gas
The commentators discuss the gas and its properties. They analyze its role in the aliens' plan and its connection to the dead. The group jokes about the importance of hygiene and the dangers of disease. They discuss the fast gas and its properties.
The Choice
The commentators discuss the choice and its significance to the plot. They analyze the Doctor's decision and its impact on the characters. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Time War
The commentators discuss the Time War and its impact on the Doctor's character. They analyze his motivations and his commitment to protecting life. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Phone Call
The commentators discuss the phone call and its significance to the plot. They analyze its role in the aliens' plan and its connection to the Doctor. The group jokes about Alexander Graham Bell and his invention. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Tropical Rainforest
The commentators discuss the tropical rainforest and its connection to the aliens. They analyze its role in the episode and its significance to the plot. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions. The group jokes about the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their reasons for doing so. They discuss the importance of trust and the dangers of betrayal.
The Next Episode
The commentators preview the next episode and its potential storylines. They analyze the characters' motivations and their relationships. The group jokes about the upcoming events and the new challenges that the Doctor and Rose will face.
The Mutton Chops
The commentators joke about shaving their beards and adopting mutton chops if they reach 2500 subscribers. They imagine what that would look like on each of them, including Brie.
The Last of the Time Lords
The commentators discuss the Doctor's status as the last of the Time Lords and the implications for his character. They analyze Rose's reaction to his loneliness and her growing connection to him.
The Doctor's Energy
The commentators discuss the Doctor's energy and his determination to save the world. They analyze his motivations and his commitment to protecting life.
The Doctor's Invitation
The commentators discuss the Doctor's invitation to Rose to travel with him. They analyze Mickey's role in Rose's life and whether she should stay with him.
The End
The commentators take a break to promote their Patreon and YouTube membership. They explain the benefits of becoming a member, including early access to videos and uncut content.
The Doctor's Philosophy
The commentators discuss the concept of the Absurd and its relevance to the episode. They analyze the Doctor's philosophy and his acceptance of the meaningless of life.
The End
The commentators discuss the time jump and its impact on Rose's relationships. They analyze Mickey's reaction to Rose's disappearance and his potential involvement in the investigation.
The End
The commentators discuss the aliens' plan to destroy Earth and their motivations for doing so. They analyze their tactics and their weaknesses.
The End
The commentators discuss the aliens' physical appearance and their lack of eyebrows. They analyze their motivations and their goals.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators preview the next episode and its potential storylines. They analyze the characters' motivations and their relationships.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future. They analyze the Doctor's actions and his decisions.
The End
The commentators discuss the end of the episode and its implications for the future.