Brief Summary
Chris Stuckmann reviews the live-action remake of "How to Train Your Dragon," directed by Dean Dublah. He notes that while live-action remakes of animated films often feel like cash grabs, this one stands out due to the original director's involvement and the evident care taken in recreating the film. The reviewer highlights the successful casting choices, the faithful recreation of the dragons' designs, and the overall respect for the source material, making it a worthwhile experience for fans of the original.
- The live-action remake is a faithful adaptation of the animated film.
- The original director's involvement ensures respect for the source material.
- Casting choices, particularly Gerard Butler, are praised.
- The design of the dragons, especially Toothless, closely resembles the animated versions.
- The film offers a new way to enjoy a beloved story without significant changes.
Introduction
The live-action adaptation of "How to Train Your Dragon," directed by Dean Dublah, mirrors the original DreamWorks film, which he co-directed with Chris Sanders. The story centers on Hiccup, an inventive Viking, and his friendship with Toothless, a night fury dragon, as they navigate an ancient threat to both Vikings and dragons on the Isle of Burke. Their bond becomes crucial for forging a new future for both species.
Live-Action Remakes and Cynicism
The reviewer expresses skepticism towards live-action remakes of animated films, viewing many as driven by financial motives rather than artistic passion. However, he notes that the "How to Train Your Dragon" remake benefits from the return of the original director, Dean Dublah, and its close adherence to the source material. This remake feels like a shot-for-shot recreation of the animated film in live action, indicating a genuine love and care for the franchise.
Why This Remake Works
The success of this live-action remake is attributed to the world of Vikings and dragons lending itself well to live action. Unlike some remakes, such as Disney's "The Lion King," where realistic animals singing created an uncanny valley effect, "How to Train Your Dragon" effectively translates its animated elements into a live-action setting. A key factor is the design of the dragons, particularly Toothless, which closely resembles their animated counterparts, avoiding a realistic, grounded interpretation.
Casting and Character Recreation
Casting is crucial in recreating beloved animated characters in live action. Mason Thames does a fantastic job making the character Hiccup his own. Gerard Butler's return to the same role he played in the original is a wise choice, as his voice and presence are perfectly suited to the character. Nico Parker as Astrid is also praised. The cast manages to embody their characters while adding their own distinctive touches, maintaining the essence of the original while feeling fresh.
Final Thoughts
The reviewer acknowledges that some may view the remake as lacking originality due to its close adherence to the original film. However, he emphasizes the potential pitfalls of deviating too much from the source material and appreciates the care taken to ensure the casting, dragon designs, production design, and costumes feel perfect. Ultimately, the live-action remake offers another way to enjoy a beloved story, told with respect and care by the franchise's original creator.