TLDR;
The video examines how online fundraising contests operate, focusing on paid votes, the portion of proceeds that may reach charities, and a lawsuit alleging that contest rules were misleading. It connects the company behind earlier contests to Colossal and raises concerns about how Colossal’s rules address security problems and legal claims.
- Contest platforms and fundraising companies may keep much of the money raised through paid votes, while charity contributions are calculated from a smaller share.
- The video cites a lawsuit involving a “Face of the Top Chef” contest and claims that paid votes were necessary to win.
- It alleges a connection between the people involved in earlier contests and Colossal, then promises further investigation into Colossal and the Starlight Foundation.
Background on Colossal and the Contest Format [0:19]
Colossal is presented as a new participant in the year’s contests, using a format that had appeared in earlier years. The video traces that format to 2019, when Darren Austin, owner of Jet Set magazine, launched the Miss Jet Setter contest. After it proved successful, he expanded the approach to contests involving chefs, horror, pets, and tattoos.
The contests combined free voting, paid voting, and a stated charitable component. According to the video, the magazines involved did not necessarily endorse or produce the contests: organizers could purchase advertising space to promote them. The speaker emphasizes that a paid advertisement is not the same as a magazine’s endorsement.
How Fundraising Companies and Charity Contributions Work [2:10]
The video describes CrowdVote as a for-profit fundraising company rather than a nonprofit. It says such companies arrange contests, secure celebrity participation or advertising, set prize amounts, and manage the competition. The speaker claims that the company’s fee and other costs are deducted before money is passed along, and that the charity may receive only a fraction of the total raised through votes.
The video also describes a second organization, DT Care, as a humanitarian fundraising company that receives a portion of the proceeds. It alleges that DT Care is obligated to donate only a percentage of what it receives, rather than a percentage of all money paid by voters. The speaker argues that this structure could leave charities with a relatively small share, while contest organizers and related companies retain the remainder after expenses.
The 2021 Lawsuit and the “Face of the Top Chef” Contest [4:47]
In 2021, two sisters filed a lawsuit against GrowVotes LLC over the “Face of the Top Chef” contest. The prize was supposed to include a feature in Bon Appétit magazine, but the magazine publicly stated that its editorial team did not endorse the contest or the promised feature. It said the organizers had purchased an advertisement and that the magazine asked them to clarify the contest’s terms.
The lawsuit alleged that the contest did not adequately disclose important information and amounted to an illegal lottery because contestants needed paid votes to win. The video says the court proceedings required GrowVotes to disclose information about how donations were calculated. It quotes a disclosure stating that the sponsor would donate 25% of proceeds earned from purchased votes to Feeding America, while clarifying that this was not a donation made directly by voters.
According to the speaker, voters were not required to read the relevant donation terms during the payment process. The video argues that the advertised 25% did not mean the charity received 25% of all money spent, because deductions and the distribution arrangement affected the final amount. It also says the case later became a class-action lawsuit and references another class-action case involving a pet competition.
The Alleged Link Between Colossal and Earlier Contest Organizers [9:03]
The speaker points to a name in a news article about the lawsuit: Mary Hagen, described as a representative associated with GrowVotes. The video then claims that Megan Hagen is running Colossal, presenting this as evidence of a connection between Colossal and the company involved in the earlier contest controversy.
The speaker argues that the connection matters because of the lawsuit’s allegations about paid voting and charity distributions. The video also claims that some participants have reported credit-card scams after making donations. It says Colossal’s rules disclaim responsibility for “malicious activities,” including hacking or credit-card issues, and include a clause that the speaker interprets as preventing participants from suing the company.
Further Questions About Colossal and Starlight [11:30]
The video closes by promising to investigate Mary Hagen, DT Care, and the Starlight Foundation in a follow-up. It questions how much money actually reaches charities, claiming that the share may be under 5%, though the transcript does not provide a detailed calculation supporting that figure.
The speaker directs viewers to links to court documents, lawsuits, and other sources in the video description. The closing presents the allegations as issues for further research and says the next installment will examine who is behind Colossal and where the Starlight Foundation is based.