TLDR;
The video discusses the announcement of the FIFA Pro World 11, highlighting the notable omission of Harry Kane despite his previous achievements, including winning the Ballon d'Or. The panel debates the inclusion of various players, particularly comparing Kane with Lionel Messi and others like Erling Haaland and Rodri. They also touch on the criteria for player selection based on performances over the year versus past reputations, especially focusing on midfield selections and goalkeeper opinions.
- Harry Kane was excluded from the FIFA Pro World 11 despite significant achievements.
- The panel debates the worthiness of players like Messi and Rodri in relation to their performances over the year.
FIFA Pro World 11 Announcement [0:01]
The FIFA Pro World 11 was announced today, showcasing the voting results from FIFA Pro members, which are players worldwide. A significant surprise is the exclusion of Harry Kane, who had recently won the Ballon d'Or. Instead, the front four features Lamine Yamal, Lionel Messi, Erling Haaland, and Kylian Mbappé. The panelists are prompted to discuss whether Harry Kane deserves a place in the team and who, if anyone, should be replaced in favour of Kane.
Debate Over Player Selection [0:25]
The discussion centres around the panelists' arguments about Harry Kane versus Lionel Messi. Stevie suggests that Kane deserves to be included based on his overall performance, reasoning that Messi’s recent play in the MLS diminishes his candidacy despite his historical greatness. Shaq supports this view by arguing that Kane’s contributions over a year outshine those of Messi, despite the latter leading Argentina to the World Cup final.
Historical Influence in Voting [1:45]
The conversation continues with various panelists questioning why players still picked Messi over Kane, suggesting that history and legacy play a crucial role in voting. They highlight that Messi's long-standing influence in football might sway opinions, leading voters to prioritise his past achievements over recent performances like those of Kane.
Midfielder Selections and Critique of Rodri [4:05]
The panel discusses midfielder selections, particularly Rodri's inclusion stemming from his World Cup performance, despite a lacklustre club season. They compare him to Declan Rice, who had a standout year in club football and influential performance for England. Panelists argue that Rice’s consistent contributions should warrant him a spot over Rodri, who only shone during a short World Cup stint.
Disagreement on Midfield Players [5:18]
As they continue to discuss prospective midfielders, Robbo mentions his preference for Jude Bellingham and Pedri over Rodri. There is contention regarding the inclusion of players like Vitinha, indicating a disagreement over who ranks among the top midfielders based on overall contributions during the season.
Goalkeeper Discussion [8:10]
The panel finally addresses the goalkeeper position, discussing David Raya's selection. Shaka acknowledges that while Raya may not be deemed the best goalkeeper in Spain, he fits well within the current team dynamics under coach De La Fuente. The conversation also hints at alternatives like Joan Garcia, showcasing the ongoing debate over the best available goalkeeping talent.
Final Thoughts [8:50]
As they wrap up, Mario shows enthusiasm for Vitinha, suggesting that his achievements, including winning back-to-back Champions League titles, should not be overlooked. The discussion highlights differing opinions within the panel about player significance and reflects the complexities of player selection based on both recent form and historical influence.
